Leadership Succession Planning: The New Economics

neumann_executive
Article by
Alicja Jaworska
Partner | Executive Search
C-suite wisdom, now in audio. Press play:

For decades, organisations built talent development on one assumption: that the best people naturally want more responsibility. A bigger team, a bigger budget, a higher title – these were treated as universal markers of success. That assumption is worth testing again.

In conversation after conversation, we meet experienced professionals who have every competence needed for a bigger role, yet are reluctant to take on the way of working that comes with it. They are not turning down influence or growth. More often, they are turning down a specific cost of responsibility: reduced autonomy, constant availability, and decision-making that keeps getting more complex.

The question for boards is therefore no longer only: do we have people capable of leading? It is: are we building roles that those people actually want to step into?

Three Research Signals Boards Shouldn’t Ignore

Three unrelated studies published in 2026 point, from different angles, to the same problem.

Wharton Executive Education’s November 2026 research on succession planning found a gap between how much leaders value it and how ready they feel: 86% call succession critical to organisational success, yet only 48% believe their own organisation is well prepared for an actual transition at the top. That gap is an argument for scrutinising the quality of succession plans, not just counting names on a talent slate.

Deloitte’s Gen Z and Millennial Survey 2026 shows that fast hierarchical promotion is not the dominant career goal for younger generations. That should not be read as an absence of leadership ambition – wanting responsibility and wanting a rapid climb are two different things, and most Gen Z and millennial respondents still say they want leadership roles eventually.

McKinsey’s The State of Organizations 2026 describes mounting pressure to redesign how companies operate, driven by new technology, rising complexity, and a shift toward durable rather than short-term productivity. That is the backdrop against which it is fair to ask whether today’s leadership roles are actually built to attract and keep the best people.

No single study proves that experienced managers are refusing promotions en masse. Together, they explain why the attractiveness of the leadership role itself deserves to be measured – alongside competence and results, not instead of them.

Would your succession plan survive the first no?

We help boards and supervisory boards tell competence apart from genuine willingness to take on a role – before it turns into a gap in the succession table.

Succession: Competence Readiness Isn’t Enough

A succession plan can look entirely convincing on paper and still fail in practice. A potential successor may tick every competence box while being unwilling to accept the travel load, the governance model, investor expectations, or the level of personal risk the role actually carries.

Boards should separate three distinct dimensions: capability – the ability to do the job; willingness – genuine readiness to take it on; and retention – the likelihood of staying engaged after the promotion.

Succession readiness is not the same as succession willingness.

It is not enough to ask who could replace the CEO or a key director. Boards also need to ask whether that person wants the role as it actually exists, not as it looks on a slide. That distinction decides whether a succession plan on paper will actually hold when it is tested.

The Swedish Lesson: What Autonomy Is Worth

In our conversations, the Swedish market offers a clear example: candidates for whom a higher salary does not compensate for lost predictability, independence, and time. This is a qualitative observation, not a representative statistic for the whole market – but it recurs often enough to take seriously.

For a growing share of senior professionals, the decision to move up has become a calculation of the role’s total value. What counts is not only compensation, but decision-making mandate, the quality of the relationship with one’s manager, administrative load, and the ability to keep some control over one’s own life.

Organisations that compete on title and pay alone can lose out to offers that give candidates more genuine agency. In practice, two companies can offer identical compensation for a similar role – and one of them still loses the hire, because the role it is offering costs the candidate more than it gives back.

Five Decisions for Boards and Supervisory Boards

  • Audit succession for real – separate successors’ competence from their motivation, mobility, and genuine readiness to take on a specific role.
  • Measure the attractiveness of leadership roles – examine the relationship between responsibility, decision-making authority, resources, and the expected way of working.
  • Design alternative paths to influence – expert tracks, ownership of transformation, or strategic projects should not automatically require managing a larger team.
  • Update how potential is assessed – alongside results and experience, weigh judgement, adaptability, collaboration, comfort with uncertainty, and fluency with AI.
  • Put leadership attractiveness on the governance agenda – discuss at board and supervisory board level not only who fills critical roles, but why people decline them, resign, or lose interest in moving up.

None of these five decisions requires a new budget or a new system. They require a different question at the next talent review.

Finding the Leaders of Tomorrow: A New Dimension of Executive Search

The future of executive search is not simply about identifying people with the right experience. Increasingly, the value lies in understanding what makes exceptional professionals choose to take on responsibility – and what drives them away from it. And whether the organisation itself is one that others actually want to lead.

Finding the Leaders of Tomorrow is no longer just about identifying leadership potential. It is about understanding what will make exceptional people choose to lead.

Are we preparing future leaders, or still expecting them to fit yesterday’s model of leadership? That question belongs on the agenda of every board that takes business continuity seriously.

About the Author

Alicja Jaworska, Partner Chair & NED at Neumann Executive, brings extensive experience in executive search, interim management, and the pharmaceutical industry. Alicja plays a pivotal role in fostering organizational transformation. Her strategic insights are highly valued in boardroom discussions, where she offers guidance on crucial matters affecting the organization’s future. With an unwavering commitment to ethical practices and a talent identification knack, Alicja identifies and nurtures board leadership roles. She drives business opportunities and adeptly manages risks, ensuring the organization maintains a balanced approach toward growth and sustainability.

We appreciate your interest in our executive search solutions. We are here to offer tailored solutions designed to elevate your organization’s potential. Connect with us to explore further.

Executive Search Neumann Executive

Find your leaders of tomorrow

*This form is being used for business purposes only. Any resume inquiries provided via contact form above, will not be proceeded at all.